Ep #224: Not Enough Doesn’t Mean Pointless: Why Small Actions Still Matter

Strong Is a Mindset with Carrie Holland | Not Enough Doesn't Mean Pointless: Why Small Actions Still Matter
Follow on Apple Podcasts | Spotify | YouTube Music

Have you ever skipped something because the version you could do didn’t feel like it counted? Maybe you didn’t have time for your full workout, couldn’t make the perfect meal, or couldn’t follow your routine exactly the way you planned. When the ideal version isn’t possible, it can be surprisingly easy to decide that doing anything smaller is pointless.

In this episode, I explore why small actions can feel so frustrating when they don’t create the full result we want. We’ll talk about why five minutes of exercise isn’t the same as a complete workout, but why dismissing those five minutes completely may be the thing keeping you stuck.

Listen in this week to learn why an action can be too small to create your ultimate goal and still matter, how smaller versions of habits help you practice the patterns that support long-term change, and how to stop treating every choice as proof that you are either succeeding or failing. You’ll discover how to give small actions the right job so they can support your goals without pretending they can do more than they actually can.


Unlock the key to longevity, health, and confidence with muscle! Whether you’re new to weight training or looking to build on your strength, this simple guide is your shortcut to getting stronger and feeling amazing. Click here to get the Simple Strength Training Guide and start your journey to a stronger, healthier you!


What You Will Discover:

  • Why “not enough to create the result” doesn’t mean “not worth doing.”
  • How small actions help you practice the patterns behind lasting habits.
  • Why the beginning of a habit is often just as important as the habit itself.
  • How all-or-nothing thinking can turn a smaller option into no action at all.
  • The difference between using a smaller habit as a starting point versus staying there forever.
  • How to give smaller actions a specific job instead of comparing them only to your biggest goal.
  • Why one choice matters less than the pattern you are creating over time.

Listen to the Full Episode:

Follow on Apple Podcasts | Spotify | YouTube Music

Featured on the Show:

Episodes Related to Why Small Actions Still Matter:

Full Episode Transcript:

This is the Strong Is a Mindset podcast, Episode #224. Have you ever skipped something altogether because what you have the time or energy for didn’t feel like enough? Today, we’re talking about why a small action can still matter even when it’s not enough to create the entire result you want.

This is the Strong Is a Mindset podcast, where you’ll learn how to build both a strong body and a strong mind by eating, moving, and thinking. I’m your host Physician, Personal Trainer, Certified Health Coach and Certified Life Coach, Carrie Holland. 

Hey, how are you? What’s new? What’s good? So, what’s good here? Well, recently, I was invited to guest coach inside someone else’s group. And during the conversation, one of the women brought up something that stayed with me. So this was a group of women who are all business owners, and I was asked to talk about taking care of ourselves when things at work get overwhelming. Because I think this is true for most women, but what often happens is that we take care of everything and everybody, and in the process, we squeeze ourselves out of the picture. And there are lots of reasons for this. In fact, that could be a whole episode in and of itself.

But the point is that we tend to let our needs go by the wayside when things get busy, and when we do this for long enough, we pay the price by ending up exhausted. And this woman was explaining that she has had a hard time exercising consistently when things get busy for her. And during the coaching session, the idea of doing a much smaller version of her workout, that came up. Meaning, if she didn’t have the time, capacity, or energy to do the full workout she originally planned, what if she did five minutes instead?

And she really struggled with that idea. And she kept coming back to the same question: what difference is five minutes actually going to make? Because if five minutes wasn’t enough to improve her fitness, then why should she bother doing it? And I’ll be honest, it was a challenging conversation. Not because she was being difficult or wasn’t listening. Really, it was difficult because she genuinely could not see the value in doing something that felt so small.

From her perspective, if the workout wasn’t long enough or challenging enough to make a noticeable difference in her fitness, it didn’t seem worth the effort of doing it at all. And honestly, I understand her point. If your goal is to get stronger, improve your cardiovascular fitness, or build endurance, a single five-minute workout is probably not going to create a meaningful physical change. Five minutes, that is not the same as a full strength training session or going for a longer walk or doing an Orange Theory class where you leave a sweaty mess. Five minutes is five minutes. And if we’re only evaluating those five minutes by how much they improve your physical fitness, it may not seem like much.

So, during this conversation, I found myself trying to explain why I still thought those five minutes mattered. And I wasn’t trying to convince her that five minutes was secretly the same as 30 minutes or that a five-minute workout would somehow give the same result as a full workout because it won’t. But because five minutes didn’t feel significant to her, she wasn’t doing the five minutes. And she also wasn’t doing the longer workout either. She was doing zero minutes, day after day. And I think that’s because the standard she created for what counted as worthwhile was leaving her with no version of the habit that she could actually practice. The only option that felt worthwhile was the one that she wasn’t currently able to do. And again, I’m not saying that critically. I think this makes a lot of sense, especially if you’re someone who is very focused on results.

And that was the part I kept thinking about after the conversation ended. Because maybe she was right and that five minutes wouldn’t make much of a difference in her fitness. But what if improving her fitness wasn’t the only thing those five minutes could accomplish? What if she was measuring the value of those five minutes by the wrong result?

And before I make a case for doing smaller things, I want to acknowledge why so many of us resist this in the first place. We say things like, “Something is better than nothing,” or “Every little bit counts,” as though that should make the five minutes feel worth it. And sure, technically, those statements can be true. But they can also feel dismissive when you’re working toward a real result. If you want to build muscle, you know you have to put in time and lift heavy weight. If you want to improve your endurance, you know that you need more than a few minutes of exercise here and there. You understand that meaningful results require meaningful effort.

And the same thing applies outside of exercise too. Eating one salad does not cancel out an entire week of fast food lunches. Going to bed 10 minutes earlier tonight, that will not correct months of five hours of sleep a night. Taking two minutes to breathe, that is not going to remove the responsibilities that are causing stress in your life. So, when someone suggests a smaller version of a bigger habit, your brain may immediately declare, “That is not enough.” And depending on the result you’re measuring, you might be right. That smaller action may not be enough to build muscle or change your eating patterns or make up for your lack of sleep or give you the outcome you ultimately want.

But I think this is where we make a big jump that is worth examining. We often go from saying, “This action is not enough to create the result I want,” to saying, “This action has zero value.” That is the leap. And those are not the same thing. Something can be too small to produce a noticeable result but still accomplish something. That is the distinction I was struggling to put into words during that coaching conversation. I didn’t want to exaggerate what five minutes could do, but I also didn’t want to dismiss it because five minutes couldn’t solve everything.

So maybe then the question is not, “Is this one small action enough to create my ultimate result?” Because it probably isn’t. That is an enormous job to give one workout. But maybe the better question here is, what else might this action be accomplishing?

So, think about it this way. When it comes to habits, we need to start by recognizing that a habit is rarely just one behavior. So as an example, when we talk about exercising, we tend to focus on the workout itself. We think about how much weight we bench pressed, how many miles we ran, the time on the bike, or how many yards we swam. But a workout doesn’t begin just with the first repetition. Before you ever pick up a weight, you’ve got to find a place for that workout within your day. You may have to change your clothes, get your water bottle and equipment, drive to the gym, or pull up the workout on your phone. You’ve got to stop whatever you were doing and transition into something else.

So there is a whole process involved in getting yourself ready to begin. And honestly, sometimes the workout itself isn’t even the hardest part. Sometimes the hardest part is the schlepping. It’s getting yourself out the door, changing your clothes when you’d rather sit on the couch, or walking into the gym. It’s creating a break in your day and deciding, “Okay, I am doing this now.” Those are all behaviors, and those behaviors have to be practiced in order for the habit to be locked in. And the same thing’s true for eating. Changing your eating habits isn’t only about the food that lands on your plate. It includes deciding what you’re going to eat, making sure the food is available, and preparing or packing something before you’re tired and hangry.

It’s also true for sleep. Sleep does not just begin when your head hits the pillow. It begins when you stop working, put down your phone, turn off the lights, and allow your day to actually be over. Those are the habits around the habit. And we often forget about that altogether. The action that gets most of the attention, like the workout, the meal, or the hours of sleep, really, that’s only one part of a much larger sequence. There are decisions to be made, preparation that needs to happen, and transitions that happen before it. And when you do a smaller version of your habit, you may not complete every part of that sequence, but you at least practiced some of it. You practice making time, you practice preparing, you practice transitioning. And most importantly, you practice beginning the habit.

None of that happens when you skip the habit altogether. So those five minutes may not give you the entire workout you wanted, but getting yourself into a place to be able to do those five minutes is giving you something else. There is the result of the action itself. That is the physical benefit that you get from completing the workout. Or the nutritional benefit of having the salad. Or the sleep you get from going to bed earlier. But beyond that, there is also the result that comes from practicing the pattern. And both pieces are super important to creating a habit that actually holds up over time.

And this is where the value of those five minutes might be a little easier to see. So yes, five minutes may only be a small fraction of the workout you wanted to do. But it is not one-sixth of a beginning. That part, that is the full 100%. Meaning, you still made the decision. You still changed your clothes. You still made time in the day for it. You still got yourself into position and started. So while the workout itself might be smaller, you still completed a full repetition of beginning.

And I actually think that’s an important distinction because when you’re trying to build a habit, you aren’t just practicing the habit itself, you’re also practicing your response to the moment right before, when it’s time to do the thing. And I don’t think we give that short little blip of time enough credit, but honestly, that is everything. Because that’s where the decision’s made. It’s in that brief but essential moment where you decide, “Am I going to follow through or not?”

And the same idea applies to eating. Planning one dinner, that may not drastically change the outcome of your nutrition for the entire week, but when you do it, you still completed one full repetition of thinking ahead and making an intentional decision. Starting your bedtime routine 10 minutes earlier, that may only give you 10 extra minutes of sleep, but you still practiced stopping what you’re doing when you said you would.

So, no, every small action does not create a huge physical result. But the physical result is not the only thing being practiced here. Sometimes you are training your muscles. Other times, you’re training your ability to begin the workout. And all of those small repetitions matter because the bigger result will eventually require you to do all of those little things repeatedly. The smaller action gives you another opportunity to practice the pattern, even when it can’t give you the entire result you’re looking for.

And here’s another side to this I think is important to recognize. When you repeatedly decide that the smaller version of the habit doesn’t matter, you often don’t stay neutral about it. So, you might be practicing a pattern you don’t even realize. And it sounds like this: If I can’t do it fully, I don’t begin. It’s subtle, but it’s sneaky, and I think a lot of us do this in different ways. If you can’t do the full workout, you don’t move at all. If you don’t have time to meal prep for the week, you make no plan for what you’ll eat. If you don’t have the time or energy to completely change the way you manage stress, you don’t take two minutes to stop and catch your breath.

In each of these situations, the smaller action can look so insignificant compared with the ideal one that it starts to feel like doing nothing, but it isn’t. Five minutes of movement is different than no movement. Planning one dinner is different from making zero decisions ahead of time. Starting your bedtime routine earlier is different from continuing to scroll because you already missed your ideal bedtime. And again, this does not mean you should never intentionally skip a workout, order takeout, stay up late, or decide that today is not the day to work on a particular habit. Sometimes doing nothing is exactly what you choose to do. But that is different from automatically doing nothing because the available option doesn’t feel like it’s good enough to count.

Because the more often your response is, “If I can’t do it fully, I won’t do it at all,” the more familiar and easier that response becomes. The cue could be anything. It could be a busy day, low energy, a schedule that goes sideways, or realizing that you just don’t have the time you thought you did to get the workout in. And then your practiced response becomes, “Never mind, I’ll try it again tomorrow, or Monday, or when things settle down.” And that becomes a habit too.

And that is what I kept coming back to after the coaching conversation. It wasn’t that this woman needed to pretend that five minutes would transform her fitness. It was that dismissing the smaller option left her waiting for a version of exercise that she wasn’t currently doing. And when the only version that counts is the ideal version, it becomes super easy to keep doing nothing while telling yourself you’re just waiting for the time when you can do it exactly right or exactly how you want to. But that time never comes and you end up staying stuck.

So maybe the question isn’t whether the smaller action is big enough to create the entire result. Maybe the question is, what pattern am I practicing when the ideal version is not possible? Do I practice making an adjustment and getting started anyway, or am I practicing waiting?

Now, with all of this said, there is a concern that comes up, and I’ve had this conversation with some of my clients. And that is, if we keep telling ourselves that five minutes counts, could we end up doing five minutes forever? Meaning, could the smaller version become another way to avoid challenging ourselves while still claiming that we’re working toward the result?

And the answer here is yes, it absolutely could. And that is why I think we need to be clear about the job of the smaller version of our habits. The smaller version is generally not meant to be the final version. There is a difference. The smaller version may be where you begin, or it might be what you come back to when you’re going through a hard stretch, or it might be how you resume a habit when you’ve gotten completely away from it. Those are all different jobs.

If you’re beginning a new habit, the smaller version, it gives you a reasonable, accessible place to start. You learn where the habit fits into your life, what gets in the way, and what you need in order to keep it up. Then, as it becomes more familiar, you can challenge yourself and ask for more. Or, say you’re going through a super demanding stretch. The smaller version of your habit will help you keep a connection to it when you don’t have the capacity to do it at 100%. So, you aren’t necessarily trying to make significant progress, you’re just trying to prevent the habit from disappearing completely.

And if you’ve let the habit go completely for weeks, months, or years, the smaller version gives you an on-ramp back into it. So instead of expecting yourself to immediately return to what you used to do, you give yourself a manageable way to re-enter the habit. So in each case, the smaller version of your habit, it’s got a purpose. But eventually, if your goal is to create a bigger result, your actions are going to have to grow with it. If you want to become significantly stronger, your workouts will need to become challenging enough to build muscle, and that’s not going to happen in five minutes. If you want to change the way you eat across the week, you will eventually need more than one planned meal. If you want more sleep, you will eventually need to find enough time to actually get that sleep.

So the smaller version of the habit does not replace what the goal requires. That is huge. I want to make sure you really hear that. The smaller version of your habit, it does not replace what your overall goal requires. But it does help you start and stay connected to the actions that will eventually get you there. So, you can think of it as a floor, not necessarily the ceiling. Because five minutes may not do much to improve your fitness today, but it can make the next workout easier to start.

And one of my coaches uses a phrase that I think fits perfectly here: It matters and it doesn’t. Meaning, that five-minute workout matters, and it also doesn’t. Finishing one workout will not determine your fitness. And if you skip it, that one decision will not ruin your fitness either. And the same is true of your other habits. One salad does not make you healthy. And one unplanned fast food run does not make you unhealthy. No single choice carries that much weight, and I think that’s important to remember because I don’t want you to hear this episode and turn every small action into a test that you’ve got to pass.

This is not about telling yourself you always have to do something, no matter what. It’s not about making one skipped workout mean you failed to reinforce the pattern or that you’re becoming someone who doesn’t exercise. At the same time, the choice still matters because it’s one repetition within a larger pattern. So, the importance isn’t in what this one action does all by itself. The importance is in what you do over and over again. The individual action matters less than the pattern it’s helping you to create. So yes, it matters and it doesn’t. You don’t need to treat every choice as if your entire health depends on getting it right. But you also don’t have to dismiss a small action just because it cannot produce the result all by itself. It’s one choice, one repetition, and one small piece of a much larger pattern. And honestly, over time, that pattern is what matters the most.

So, now, after everything we’ve talked about so far, how do you apply all of this without dismissing the smaller action or pretending it will accomplish more than it actually will? Because remember, the goal here is to be real and be honest with yourself. So, if you are considering the smaller version of your habit, I think it helps to be clear about what you’re asking it to do. So give it a specific job. Because if you compare every small action to your ultimate goal, it will almost always look inadequate. If you compare your five-minute workout to your goal of becoming significantly stronger, of course it’s going to look pointless. If you compare your one salad to your goal of changing the way you eat, it’s not going to seem like much.

But maybe that’s not the job you give those actions today. Maybe the job of your five-minute workout is to help you stay in the game when you are going through a really busy season between work and home. Maybe the job of planning one dinner is to interrupt multiple nights in a row of automatically ordering takeout and get you thinking ahead again. So, you’re not pretending those actions will create the entire result. You’re not faking yourself out here, okay? You’re deciding what you want the smaller version to help you practice right now, today. And this is just another example of meeting yourself where you’re at.

So, did the five-minute workout dramatically improve your fitness? No, but that wasn’t the job today. Its job was to help you stay in the habit, and it did. Did planning one meal overhaul your nutrition? No, but its job was to help you make one decision before you got tired.

So, with all of this in mind, this is the question I want you to ask: what part of the habit am I practicing here? Maybe you’re practicing beginning. Maybe you’re practicing planning ahead. Maybe you’re practicing following through on what you said you were going to do. Or maybe it’s maintaining some connection to the habit during a week that is full-on chaos. But once you know the job of the smaller version of your habit, you can let it do the job you gave it, and then let that be enough.

So, going back to the conversation that started this whole episode, I can totally understand why the woman questioned the value of five minutes. She wasn’t wrong that five minutes is not enough to improve her fitness in the way she wanted. The problem was what happened next. Five minutes wasn’t enough to create the result, so it no longer felt worth doing at all. And I think that’s the leap I want you to pay attention to in your own life.

Where in your own life have you decided that if you cannot do it enough or do it a certain way, there is no point in beginning? Because maybe the version that’s available to you based on your current life and your schedule really isn’t enough to create the entire result you want. You can acknowledge that honestly. You don’t have to over-exaggerate the impact or convince yourself that it’s something it’s not. But before you dismiss it completely, consider whether there’s still something in there worth practicing.

Maybe today is not the day you make leaps and bounds on your progress. Maybe instead, today’s the day you practice beginning, planning, stopping, or just showing up for yourself for a habit that matters to you. That doesn’t mean you lower your expectations forever. It also doesn’t mean you stop asking more of yourself when you have the capacity to do more. It just means you stop telling yourself it only counts if you can do the ideal version. Because a small action and no action, they are not the same. The smaller action may not be enough to change your ultimate result today, but it may be just enough to change what you do next. All right?

And if you want help with this, let’s go. When you coach with me, we figure out what’s getting in the way of the habits you want, create a plan that works in your actual life, and practice adjusting that plan when you can’t do the ideal version. Check out my website. Send me a message at www.CarrieHollandMD.com/contact, and let’s talk about how coaching can help you build habits you can actually keep going. All right? Thank you again for hanging out with me, and I’ll catch you again next week.

—

Hey if you want to build muscle but don’t know where to start, I’ve got you covered. Head over to CarrieHollandMD.com/buildstrength and download my free guide to help you maximize your strength training. Inside, you’ll find the essential exercises for building muscle, plus simple one, two, and three-day workout plans you can follow with just dumbbells and a bench.

You’ll also find strength training tips to help you train smarter and see real results. My goal is to help you get strong and this strength-training guide will help you do it. Go to CarrieHollandMD.com/build strength and check it out.

Thank you for listening to the Strong Is a Mindset podcast. If you want to learn more about how to build both a strong mind and a strong body by eating, moving, and most importantly, thinking, check out CarrieHollandMD.com.

Enjoy the Show?

Scroll to Top